Combination Boiler vs Heat Pump System
Compare these two popular boiler types to find which suits your home best
Combination Boiler
All-in-one boiler providing heating and hot water on demand without the need for separate tanks or cylinders.
Heat Pump System
Low-carbon heating system extracting heat from air or ground.
Key Statistics
Advantages Comparison
Combination Boiler Advantages
Space-saving design
No need for separate hot water cylinder or cold water tank, freeing up valuable cupboard space.
Instant hot water
Hot water is heated on demand, so you never run out and don't waste energy heating a tank.
Lower installation costs
Simpler installation with fewer components means lower upfront costs.
Energy efficient
Only heats water when needed, reducing energy waste.
Good water pressure
Water comes directly from the mains, providing strong pressure.
Cheaper to run
No heat loss from storing hot water, making running costs lower.
Heat Pump System Advantages
Low carbon emissions
Uses renewable energy from air or ground, dramatically reducing carbon footprint.
Government grants available
Eligible for Boiler Upgrade Scheme with grants up to £7,500.
Lower running costs long-term
Can be 3-4 times more efficient than traditional boilers.
No fuel storage needed
Doesn't require gas connection or oil tank.
Can provide cooling in summer
Some systems can reverse to provide air conditioning.
Long lifespan
Typically lasts 20+ years with proper maintenance.
Disadvantages Comparison
Combination Boiler Disadvantages
Limited hot water flow rate
Water flow reduces if multiple taps are used simultaneously.
Not ideal for multiple bathrooms
Struggles to supply enough hot water when demand is high.
Performance depends on mains pressure
Poor water pressure will result in weak flow from taps.
No backup hot water
If boiler breaks down, you have no heating or hot water.
Temperature can fluctuate
Water temperature may vary when multiple outlets are used.
Heat Pump System Disadvantages
High upfront cost
Initial installation costs £7,000-£14,000 even with grants.
Requires larger radiators
Often need to upgrade radiators or add underfloor heating.
Lower water temperature
Heats water to 45-50°C vs 70-80°C from gas boiler.
Space needed for unit
Outdoor unit required with space around it for airflow.
Less effective in very cold weather
Efficiency drops when outdoor temperature falls below -5°C.
Noise concerns
Outdoor unit can generate noise, may affect neighbors.
Space Requirements Comparison
Combination Boiler
Boiler unit
Required700mm H x 400mm W x 300mm D
Heat Pump System
Outdoor heat pump unit
Required1200mm H x 1000mm W x 500mm D
Hot water cylinder
Required1800mm H x 600mm diameter
Indoor control unit
Required300mm H x 200mm W x 100mm D
Annual Running Costs Comparison
| Property Size | Combination Boiler | Heat Pump System | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Small (1-2 bed) | £950 | £850 | £100(Heat Pump System cheaper) |
| Medium (3-4 bed) | £1375 | £1150 | £225(Heat Pump System cheaper) |
| Large (4+ bed) | £1800 | £1450 | £350(Heat Pump System cheaper) |
Which Should You Choose?
Choose Combination Boiler If...
✓ Best suited for:
Small to medium homes (1-3 bedrooms) with 1-2 bathrooms, flats, properties with limited space, homes with good mains water pressure
✗ Not suitable for:
Large homes with multiple bathrooms being used simultaneously, properties with poor mains water pressure, homes with very high hot water demand
Choose Heat Pump System If...
✓ Best suited for:
Well-insulated properties, homes with space for outdoor unit, new-build properties, properties off gas grid, homes with larger radiators or underfloor heating, environmentally-conscious homeowners eligible for government grants
✗ Not suitable for:
Poorly insulated properties, homes with very limited outdoor space, properties with small radiators that cannot be upgraded, properties where installation cost is prohibitive, homes requiring high-temperature heat
Ready to Get a New Boiler?
Get free quotes from Gas Safe registered installers
Compare prices for both Combination Boilers and Heat Pump Systems